Tuesday, March 18, 2014

Will we ever learn?

Our lives are short and I haven´t lived long enough to experience any drastic changes of the world we live in. The perhaps first dramatic historic event that I consciously experienced was 9/11. I remember watching the planes crash into the Twin Towers on TV. Back then, it felt like a rather distant event. I hadn´t seen much of the world nor did I understand that much of it. I have always considered the reaction of the U.S. counterproductive. Answering violence with violence felt wrong for me even back then. It could only cause more hatred and violence. 
Today, I have a much better understanding of the world. I have been to many different countries and met and lived with many different nationalities. It made me a strong believer of cultural dialogue, inclusion and peace. True, in many parts of the world xenophobia, nationalism and the resultant violence are still omnipresent. In Europe we had learnt, I believed. We had created a world where things could be solved without wars, I believed. This belief and this world are rapidly falling apart. The European project itself is in a precarious state. Greed and the subsequent economic excesses have damaged our economies and disillusioned substantial parts of our societies. Xenophobia and generally blaming things on outside factors instead of taking responsibility are on the rise. I still believed all this can be mended and we can emerge stronger from this crisis. 
Events in the Ukraine have changed all this. Whatever the shortcomings of Western policies, whatever the truth among so many lies and so much propaganda, whoever is to blame, fact is that imperialism and war have returned to Europe. It seems that the policy of inclusion and integration of our neighbours and more particularly Russia have simply failed. What is called soft power is perceived as weak by those who prefer to rule by force. I fear there will be less of Steinmeier and more of Kissinger again. I still believe in inclusion, intercultural dialogue and peaceful resolution of conflicts. I equally fear I have few arguments to counter those who ask for a stronger military again and to counter force with force. In fact, I started comprehending why the U.S. believes a policy of strength is the only way to secure peace. Not in the whole world, but at least in the Western world. As much as I want to believe that the people have changed from 80 years ago when Germans started following a calamitous ideology and an insane leader, I have to admit that this seems to be an increasingly naïve belief. Manipulation and propaganda work very much the same way as they did then and the consequences are much the same: violence, war and suffering. 
While it is somehow distant for many Europeans, the threat is real for the Baltics and other neighbouring countries. Soon we might understand that we are all Ukrainians. For me fighting for freedom has always had something contradictory. It still has, but maybe this is soon going to be our reality again. I am afraid the world will never learn. I am not afraid to be proven wrong; I indeed hope I will be.